NHL 2023/2024 Fantasy Season Rankings – Defenseman (11.-15.)

by: Domagoj Erbežnik

If you go heavy with forwards or even goalies these are some defensemen you could draft for your team and still be in a good position for the rest of your draft. All players in this part are still clear no. defenseman with and a big part of their teams’ power play. McAvoy and Carlson hold the most upside in this part of the rankings but the question with them is if they can stay healthy for a full season and again be around 80 points.

11
Josh Morrissey - Winnipeg Jets
2022/2023 stats: 78 games played, 76 points (16 goals, 60 assists), +2 plus/minus, 28 PP points

Morrissey is coming off the best career year by far as his career high in points before last season was at 37, so he doubled that total in last season. He is a clear No. 1 defenseman on the Jets but his numbers should take a bit of a dip in 2023/2024 but he should still be around 60 to 65 points. His Plus/minus is around 0 over the last few years and that is a category you should be aware if you plan to draft him. Also, expect his shot total again to be between 160 and 180 which is just above 2 shots per game.

Good categories: PP Points
Bad categories: Plus/Minus
12
John Carlson - Washington Capitals
2022/2023 stats: 40 games played, 29 points (9 goals, 20 assists), -7 plus/minus, 12 PP points

Carlson is a very interesting player in this year’s fantasy drafts as he falls lower than in any of the last 4-5 years. He had an injury last season but if he stayed healthy he would likely reach over 17 goals and around 60 points with over 250 shots on goal and at his current draft value those are some impressive numbers. He is 33 years old and still has some good years to give to fantasy managers if he can stay healthy. Washington isn’t expected to a playoff them this year so beware of his plus/minus which will likely be around -15. Still, he is a very good pick at his current ADP if you are in need of a defenseman.

Good categories: Goals, Shots
Bad categories: Plus/Minus
13
Brent Burns - Carolina Hurricanes
2022/2023 stats: 82 games played, 61 points (18 goals, 43 assists), +19 plus/minus, 23 PP points

At age 38 Burns is still one of the most reliable fantasy defensemen in the league. He again played a full season last year and still averaged over 23 minutes on ice per game. He is a part of one of the best teams in the league and that is a big bust for his plus/minus and being a part of PP1 should bring a bunch of easy points for him again. He will again fire over 200 shots on goal and when you count that up he is a very good fantasy asset. The Hurricanes have a bunch of great offensive defensemen like Deangelo and Orlov so if he doesn’t perform on power play he could easily be replaced at some point.

Good categories: Plus/Minus, Shots
Bad categories: No bad categories to highlight
14
Brandon Montour - Florida Panthers
2022/2023 stats: 80 games played, 73 points (16 goals, 57 assists), +9 plus/minus, 33 PP points

Montour has played two straight full seasons with the Panthers but he will miss about a month to start this season. Last year he finished with 70 points and was a big part of PP1 and Panthers’ success in the playoffs. The question is if can match those numbers this season and I wouldn’t expect him to do that. The Panthers will be in a fight for playoff in the best division but they will still likely finish behind the Leafs and the Lightning. There are better options than Montur in this year’s fantasy draft and I would avoid drafting him.

Good categories: PP points
Bad categories: Health
15
Charlie McAvoy - Boston Bruins
2022/2023 stats: 67 games played, 52 points (7 goals, 45 assists), +29 plus/minus, 19 PP points

McAvoy is a great hockey player and his numbers over his career back that up. He is coming into the season healthy and should start the year as a member of PP1 which could provide much better numbers for his fantasy production. His lowest number in the plus/minus category over his NHL career is at +14 with him having combined +60 plus/minus over the last 2 seasons so having him can be a great asset in that category. He is a great overall player and a very good fantasy asset if he can stay healthy for a full season.

Good categories: Plus/Minus
Bad categories: No bad categories to highlight